Perfectly Soft Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe | Yummly

Perfectly Soft Peanut Butter Cookies

THE RECIPE CRITIC(46)
Shari Blodgett Klenow: "Followed directions to the letter, they turned ou…" Read More
10Ingredients
15Minutes
170Calories
Read Directions
Add to Meal Planner

Add to Meal Planner

Ingredients

US|METRIC
  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1 cup white sugar
  • 1 cup brown sugar (packed)
  • 1 cup butter (softened)
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2 1/2 cups flour
  • 1/4 cup sugar (for rolling if desired)
  • Did you make this?
    Add All to Shopping List
    Add to Meal Planner

    NutritionView More

    170Calories
    Sodium5% DV125mg
    Fat14% DV9g
    Protein6% DV3g
    Carbs6% DV19g
    Fiber3% DV<1g
    Calories170Calories from Fat80
    % DAILY VALUE
    Total Fat9g14%
    Saturated Fat4g20%
    Trans Fat
    Cholesterol25mg8%
    Sodium125mg5%
    Potassium65mg2%
    Protein3g6%
    Calories from Fat80
    % DAILY VALUE
    Total Carbohydrate19g6%
    Dietary Fiber<1g3%
    Sugars12g24%
    Vitamin A4%
    Vitamin C
    Calcium2%
    Iron4%

    * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your Daily Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.

    Reviews(46)

    Followed directions to the letter, they turned out really good. I put chocolate chips on top before baking. I only cooked them for 9 mins don’t over bake if you want them soft. If you like a crisp cookie just bake 2-3 mins longer
    DJ DJ 9 days ago
    Delicious great simple
    Victoria Whipple 10 days ago
    The recipe is a good one - easy to assemble even without a mixer - I was lazy and did not want to get my kitchen aide mixer out...😌 waiting now to taste the results...and they are very good. I used Costco natural organic peanut butter, which is very runny and Crisco butter flavor baking stick. They are very soft cookies so I had to bake them longer.
    best cookies will definitely make again
    Melanie Kennedy 21 days ago
    The cookies do turn out perfectly soft,crunchy and delicious. Try this recipe if you are looking for a peanut butter cookie with a subtle taste of PB!
    Monica Stone 21 days ago
    excellent i only had crunchy peanut butter but still was great.. i think i liked it better to be honest!
    James Kearn 25 days ago
    PB cookies of dreams. I was impatient and only let the dough cool for an hour, to compensate for their stickyness I coated my pressing fork with sugar. Baking for 14 minutes was perfect.
    pink snowkitten a month ago
    They were delicious! The only thing I would change would be a little more peanut butter for stronger flavor. Thank you!
    Chrystal Burns a month ago
    they turned out great
    Sand a month ago
    This is my fist time making peanut cookies and I'm so glad I had chosen this recipe. Could've not been any simpler. The result was soft and they seem to dissolve in your mouth. Don't over mix the dough or you'll have tough cookies. I made these cookies for my son and plus I have three jars of peanut butter I needed to use up. Instead of using a fork to press them down I used a potatoe masher, sprayed with Pam so the dough wouldn't stick. The result as you can see was peferct IMO.
    Arielle J. a month ago
    Delicious I added a 1/4 more of pb
    Mitch a month ago
    I've never really baked before but these were super easy to make and turned out great. I swapped the rolling sugar for chocolate chips.
    Gabrielle a month ago
    These came out amazing. Thank you for sharing 💕
    Starr 2 months ago
    These cookies are easy to make and taste delicious! I will keep this recipe and continue to make for my family.
    Susan D. 2 months ago
    made these as instructions except for no dip in sugar and needed10 minutes to cook. came out very nice. made about 45 really big cookies. easy put together and will make again
    Nkenge Bergan 2 months ago
    Wonderfully yummy!!!
    MM 3 months ago
    Stuck to the recipe and they were just ok. I like mine with a stronger peanut butter flavor,so more pb, less butter and sugar next time.
    Paul 4 months ago
    Come a little flat. Next time I’d add a little more flour but they came great!
    Daequana Bates 4 months ago
    They where very good
    Mandy Winkert 4 months ago
    They turned out so yummy and soft. My boyfriend said “better then grandma’s”. Definitely making them again!
    Amy Heuangvilay 4 months ago
    Came out perfect! I used whole wheat flower and self rising flower. I also added brewers yeast! (A little addition for nursing mom here! 😊) added some dark choc. Chips and white choc. Chips as well!
    Coupon Mom 5 months ago
    My family enjoyed these soft and fluffy cookies.
    Stacy Overby 5 months ago
    Turned out amazing. I just followed the recipe and didn’t do the optional sugar roll. Perfectly sweet and soft
    Ciara Akers 5 months ago
    These turned out great! I didn’t have a cup of butter so I used 7 tbsp and they are super soft and chewy!!
    Jen 5 months ago
    I used Jiff peanut butter, which I find sweet so I cut back on the sugar (3/4 w and 3/4 b). Glad I did because otherwise it would have been too sweet. Like others have commented, I had to bake mine longer -- 15 minutes. Very yummy and will definitely make again!
    Rebecca H. 5 months ago
    Great! Mine took 11-12 minutes using parchment paper. I also used a cookie scoop. I didn't roll in sugar but used sugar on my fork to make marks. They have crunchy edges and soft centers,
    Haley Winterhalter 6 months ago
    Delicious! I used parchment paper on the baking sheets to make sure the bottoms wouldn't burn. The cookies also took about 10 or 11 minutes. It's all in how big you make the dough balls!
    Lisa 7 months ago
    Husband loved these cookies
    Jason 7 months ago
    Awesome recipe. I added chopped up dark chocolate and salted caramel sauce on top. My wife eat the whole batch! So good.
    Cazares 7 months ago
    delicious.. very easy to make my family loved them

    PlanShop