Add All to Shopping List
Add to Meal Planner
|Calories1870Calories from Fat1240|
|% DAILY VALUE|
|Calories from Fat1240|
|% DAILY VALUE|
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your Daily Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
Christina 8 months ago
EXCELLENT! Peanut Butter Pie Perfection! A recipe of few ingredients and a lot of fun. Cookie crumbs and peanut butter paste, better than finger paints..... One of the best pies in my lifetime.
CDT a year ago
WOW! So totally decadent. Tastes like a Reese’s in pie form. Delicious! Only annoyance is that it was a little hard to cut at 1st. Probably should’ve left it on the counter a few mins before serving, but we like it to be cold & firm. Other than that it was a big hit!
Caligirl a year ago
Amazing! One of the best desserts of all time; declared by all of my testers :)
Jennifer C. a year ago
Drooooool! So delicious, Will be making again for the next celebration, whatever it is!
Down a year ago
I made this and it was absolutely decadent delicious incredible dessert. 10 out of 10
Kelly K a year ago
My family told me this is professional status! This dessert was a HUGE hit in my house! Thank you!
Laura Beth D. a year ago
Excellent!!! Making it again only two weeks later!
Tammy a year ago
very easy to make and sooo good
Tricia a year ago
Skip the Oreo crust, makes it wayyyy too rich. The peanut butter chocolate taste is exactly what I wanted though.
Kimberly a year ago
This was easy and oh so delicious.
Shannon O'Grady a year ago
Great, added a little whipped cream to the peanut butter layer and used a spring form pan. So good!
Holly S. 2 years ago
So easy and deeeeelish!!! Followed to recipe exactly and it was fantastic!
EmilyKing 2 years ago
My go-to dessert for anything and everything. The peanut butter part needs vanilla though.
Paige Myrick 3 years ago
Better if it were healthier, but delicious! Next time I am going to substitute the cream.
Laura N. 3 years ago
easy and tasty!!!!! it was a hit easter family gathering will make it agaib
YK 3 years ago
I made this for a friend who loves Reese's and it satisfied their taste buds! It was a bit too heavy for me, though. I advise adding less powdered sugar. Overall: very easy and quick, and anyone who loves peanut butter is in for a treat!
Emily D. 3 years ago
Wonderful! It's very rich though, and the crust doesn't turn out too crusty, it's much softer than I expected. Also, I would probably use less sugar next time, I had a super small slice and I could feel it. The top layer cracks, so the pie is a bit difficult to serve, but the taste is 100%.
Trenee G. 4 years ago
The Oreos barely made it into the pie crust! I loved that this recipe had only a few ingredients and that it was so simple and quick to make. It satisfied my sweet tooth, but I can only have one very thin slice at a time. Having a bigger slice makes me feel like I just ate 8 Reese's cups. Still good!