Copycat Panera Macaroni and Cheese

SHUGARY SWEETS(5)
Danny B.: "Most awesome top it with some ritz crackers and e…" Read More
9Ingredients
25Minutes
660Calories

Ingredients

US|METRIC
  • 1/4 cup unsalted butter
  • 1/4 cup all purpose flour
  • 1 cup milk (I used skim)
  • 2 cups heavy cream
  • 2 cups white cheddar (shredded, I used Cabot seriously sharp cheddar)
  • 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1 teaspoon dry mustard
  • 1 pound pasta (cooked, cavatapppi, shells, or elbow)
  • Add All to Shopping List
    Add to Meal Planner
    Made it

    NutritionView More

    660Calories
    Sodium16% DV380mg
    Fat68% DV44g
    Protein35% DV18g
    Carbs17% DV50g
    Fiber8% DV2g
    Calories660Calories from Fat400
    % DAILY VALUE
    Total Fat44g68%
    Saturated Fat26g130%
    Trans Fat
    Cholesterol145mg48%
    Sodium380mg16%
    Potassium280mg8%
    Protein18g35%
    Calories from Fat400
    % DAILY VALUE
    Total Carbohydrate50g17%
    Dietary Fiber2g8%
    Sugars4g8%
    Vitamin A30%
    Vitamin C2%
    Calcium30%
    Iron10%

    * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your Daily Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.

    Reviews(5)

    Danny B. 7 days ago
    Most awesome top it with some ritz crackers and enjoy
    Diana 14 days ago
    I’ve actually never had Panera’s Mac and cheese, so Idk how close this recipe is to the real thing, but it’s delicious! My kids don’t normally eat Mac and cheese (I know, weird), but my 3 year old ate this as leftovers for days! I used sharp cheddar cheese instead of white cheddar, but this is my new Mac and cheese recipe!
    Tasha 2 months ago
    I agree not exactly like Panera but still very good. It’s very cheesy but even more creamy. It reminded me of a cross between a fettuccine Alfredo and mac & cheese. Definitely better than boxed Mac and cheese
    Brooke Urbaniak 3 months ago
    The mustard ruined it. Not really a fan of this one.
    Samuel McCarty 3 months ago
    It doesn’t taste all like Panera... but it tasted really good. I substituted white cheddar for a Mexican blend and made my own whipping cream. Absolutely stunning 😋
    Ava 4 months ago
    it’s awesome! i live it!!!
    Maggifer 4 months ago
    I'm personally not a fan of pepper, but the recipe was great and turned out perfect!
    Ambrosia Brushaber 4 months ago
    if you add extra cheese and diffrent cheeses then it tastes way better but it was still good.
    Cassi D. 4 months ago
    Turned out great. I used a mix of medium cheddar and sharp white cheddar. I also added a pinch of garlic and onion powder.
    sav 4 months ago
    Perfect, creamy, and delicious!!
    Jason B. 4 months ago
    The direction on how to make it are very poor, luckily I had experience with make this type of Mac and cheese from a different recipe. This was very good! I did add more cheese than the recipe called for which then required me to add more salt and pepper for my taste. Overall, I would highly recommend this recipe to anyone who loves Mac and cheese.
    Nadia 6 months ago
    Tried with parmesan cheese and it's great!
    Mike Stenger 7 months ago
    I used shredded cheese and it turned out just fine.
    Sieg 7 months ago
    Awesome - definitely will make it again!
    Upchurch 7 months ago
    Was perfect the it was, everyone loved it
    Anitra 7 months ago
    Good, but needed a little extra seasoning.
    pretty good! nice and thick with a slight sweetness! very filling and goes nicely with bread. doesn’t taste exactly like the panera mac n cheese but that’s not a bad thing!
    Keith 9 months ago
    A little too much flower seem to make it a bit gritty. Other than that it was very unhealthy and so, so good
    Wyffels-Henry 9 months ago
    easy to make and very delicious!
    It was easy to follow. I added my own seasonings for additional flavor.
    Scott 9 months ago
    Yum! Just like Panera! I’d cut back on the salt.
    Eileen 10 months ago
    It was ok. My kid liked it.
    Katelynn Gentile a year ago
    It was okay, kinda bland. I added more seasoning after I tasted it (paprika, garlic powder, onion powder) but it just needed something else. I used the same cheese in the recipe too. Maybe breadcrumbs and another type of cheese will make it better? Will try it again, but I’ll tweak it more.
    kkinnan a year ago
    Easy to make and delicious. Used Tillamook Extra Sharp White cheese.
    Alan R. a year ago
    This was the best Mac n cheese I’ve ever had homemade. That’s saying a lot because I’m a fat guy, so I know what I’m talking about! I used whole milk instead of skim and I used garlic salt. It came out so thick and cheesy, it stuck to the pasta very well. As the mixture of cream, flour and butter begins to bubble, give it a minute or two of whisking to make sure it gets thick then add the cheese. I will definitely be making this again!
    Michelle V. a year ago
    yummm easy to make. luv how i can adjust the amounts i use
    Terrie Swank a year ago
    Creamy Mac and cheese dish loved it
    Joann 2 years ago
    it was absolutely wonderful everyone loved it i will deff make it again!!!! jojo😘
    KJ Brown 2 years ago
    First time homemade mac and cheese has turned out for me! Next time I’ll use normal white cheddar and not extra sharp, it was a bit strong
    Karlene 2 years ago
    I absolutely love this recipe! I used to be able to find white cheddar at Costco, but they don't have it anymore. regular cheddar works just fine. This is my family's favorite mac and cheese recipe.

    PlanShop