You've Been Eating Your Peeps All Wrong
AboutCareersContact UsFAQs
BookmarkletYum Button

You've Been Eating Your Peeps All Wrong

Peeps are the ultimate sugary salute to Easter. There's no way to get enough, but if your strategy for eating as many as you can is just popping them in your mouth, we're here to tell you that you're doing it all wrong.

Disclosure: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, meaning if you follow the link and make a purchase, Yummly makes a commission.

Do you love Peeps? You’re not alone. And this year more than ever, their oddball charm may be just what's in order to bring some cheer to your house. If you're grabbing them on a planned grocery run or ordering them for delivery, now's the time: Easter is a little more than a week away, and last-minute shopping trips to buy just one fun thing really aren't what they used to be, are they?

Yes, it’s true that at their core they’re “just” marshmallows. But with their pastel hues and sugary coating, to fans they’re more than that. (Peeps trivia time: The Pennsylvania company behind them says they make enough in one year to circle the Earth twice. Yellow is the most popular color.)

These marshmallow chicks and bunnies spring up around Easter, brightening our lives with colorful whimsy. But what if you want to go beyond just biting a Peeps bunny or a Peeps chick? Take a peep at these Peeps recipes.

Homemade Marshmallow Peeps

A picture of small marshmallow rabbits coated in colored sugar on a plate

Homemade Marshmallow Peeps by 52 Kitchen Adventures

First things first: If you find yourself unable to buy Peeps or without Peeps in your Easter basket and you want a solid do-it-yourself project, look no further than homemade marshmallow Peeps. The ingredients list is surprisingly short! Cold water, gelatin, and sugar, plus colored sugar and cocoa powder for decorating your homemade Peeps. Yes, if you have a silicone bunny mold, this is the time to use it. No bunny mold? No problem. You can use cookie cutters.

Peeps S'mores

A picture of stacked graham crackers with melted chocolate and pink Peeps

Peeps S'mores by Sally's Baking Addiction

Sally’s Baking Addiction gives the campfire classic the indoor Peeps treatment. Regular marshmallows are swapped out for Easter Peeps sandwiched between graham crackers and combined with delicious melty chocolate. When it’s all assembled, you’ll see the bright color of the Peeps peeking out from the inside of the graham cracker sandwich.

Easter Peeps Pretzel Rods

A picture of pretzel rods coated in white chocolate and candy sprinkles, with a bunny Peeps on top

Easter Peeps Pretzel Rods by Thrifty Diy Diva

These simple, ingenious noshes combine the salty and sweet with white chocolate-coated pretzel rods teaming up with Peeps and little pastel candies for an easy Easter goody. Do you have kids who want to get their hands on some of these? You can let them pitch in! It’s an activity and a treat rolled into one.

PEEPS® Easter Garden Cake

A picture of a chocolate cake decorated with chocolate frosting, Peeps bunnies, frosting grass, and frosting carrots

PEEPS® Easter Garden Cake by Betty Crocker

Peeps in the garden! What could be more spring-like than seeing them pop up as Peter Rabbits amongst a bed of Mr. McGregor’s carrots? Chocolate cake, frosting, and cookie crumbs create a properly earthy tableau, and green and orange decorator icing easily become vegetables and verdant grass. Cake mix and purchased frosting make this diy project delightfully easy to pull off.

S'mores Peeps Pops

A picture of a bunny Peeps with the bottom coated in chocolate and graham crackers, with a bite taken out

S'mores Peeps Pops by The Bitter Side of Sweet

This s’mores incarnation dips the Peeps in chocolate and showers the coating with graham cracker crumbs for a treat The Bitter Side of Sweet says will call to mind spring with just a glance. Popsicle sticks add even more whimsy to this clever Easter bite. If you use decorative sticks, it’s another opportunity to add a pop of color.

Sunflower Peeps Cake

A picture of a chocolate cake with a ring of yellow chick Peeps on top and a center of chocolate chips

Sunflower Peeps Cake by Erica's Sweet Tooth

Springtime is flower time and this centerpiece cake brings spring into the kitchen. Bright yellow Peeps chicks line the edge of the frosted cake, with chocolate chips in the center re-creating the “seeds” to round out the sunflower look. The recipe tells you how to bake a yellow cake and make chocolate frosting from scratch, but you could easily go for a cake mix and a container of frosting and make a beeline to the decorations.

Marshmallow Peep Milkshakes

A picture of pastel-colored milkshakes decorated with Peeps and sugar rims

Marshmallow Peep Milkshakes by Wear and Where and Well

Perch a Peep on the rim of a milkshake that’s made with melted Peeps for a dose of color and fun. A little food coloring matches the ice cream color to the Peeps color and helps tie it all together. Take advantage of your supply of Easter candy and add some mini candy Easter eggs as a garnish. 

PEEPS Peanut Butter S’mores Dip

A picture of a glass baking dish filled with lightly toasted Peeps with chocolate underneath and some graham crackers on the side

PEEPS Peanut Butter S’mores Dip by Happy Go Lucky

Chocolate chips, Reese’s Peanut Butter cups, graham crackers, and Peeps get piled together to create a spring celebration of sweetness with a colorful top that’s unmistakably Peeps. It does spend a little time in the oven, but nothing that will slow you down. Cook time: just 6 to 8 minutes. 

Layered Peeps Rice Krispie Treats

A picture of slices of striped Rice Krispies Treats with some Peeps in the background

Layered Peeps Rice Krispie Treats by Yellow Bliss Road

Rice Krispies Treats get the Peeps treatment in this beautifully colorful and deliciously crispy recipe. A Peeps four-color pack is the magic touch to create the rainbow loaf, which you then slice to serve — with additional Peeps on the side, if you like.

Peeps Sugar Cookies

A picture of shortbread cookie squares topped with icing, Peeps, and colored sugar

Peeps Sugar Cookies by Sweet and Savory Meals

These Peeps cookies take a classic sugar cookie and plop a Peep on top with some sugar sprinkles for a pretty Easter flourish. Match the sugar color to the Peep color for a polished look that pops.

Bountiful Bunny Peep Easter Cake

A picture of a layer cake decorated with pastel Peeps and edible grass

Bountiful Bunny Peep Easter Cake by The Rebel Chick

This Peeptastic Peeps bunny cake from The Rebel Chick features a ring of Peeps surrounding it and a crown of Peeps atop, for a look reminiscent of a festive Easter bonnet. Just a dab of frosting is all it takes to attach the bunnies to the edge of the cake. Edible Easter grass provides another cute and clever decorative touch.

Hippity Hoppity Cupcakes

A picture of cupcakes decorated with green candy sprinkles and Peeps dipped in chocolate and sprinkles

Hippity Hoppity Cupcakes by Queen of Reviews

Tinted frosting tops chocolate cupcakes (cake mix is your friend here). And for the pièce de résistance (Peeps de résistance?): a chocolate-dipped marshmallow Peep poking up from the field of frosting.

Dressed Up Peeps

A picture of Peeps decorated with white chocolate to look like tuxedos

Dressed Up Peeps by Midwestern Moms

Perhaps you’re thinking Peeps look a little too casual as is? Maybe they could use a suit (or a tux!) Have we got the recipe for you. This recipe takes Peeps and candy melts — use whichever color you like, according to the color of your Peeps — to create the most elegant Peeps you’ve ever seen. Midwestern Moms says you can even use melted chocolate for a Peeps tuxedo. Never again will anyone say that your Peeps are underdressed. (Wait. Was someone saying that?)

Hungry For More Peeps? 

If you're just starting your Peeps adventures, we have loads more recipes to explore your Peeps predilection.